Skip to content

Urgent urology symptoms What to do

Self-employed urologists order more imaging

Urology TodayPublished November 8, 20103 min read

Key points

  • A patient may be twice as likely to undergo an x-ray, ultrasound or other diagnostic imaging test after seeing a self-employed urologist as opposed to an employed urologist on salary, suggests a new study.
  • “In the same patient, a medical problem would be evaluated—and perhaps treated—differently by employed versus self-employed urologists,” Dr.
  • The researchers looked at more than 37 million outpatient visits to urologists across the U.S., using data from the National Ambulatory Medical Care Survey conducted in 2006 and 2007.
  • Most of the imaging was indicated for a benign enlargement of the prostate, kidney stones or the presence of blood in the urine.

A patient may be twice as likely to undergo an x-ray, ultrasound or other diagnostic imaging test after seeing a self-employed urologist as opposed to an employed urologist on salary, suggests a new study.

While other factors may be at play, the finding builds on growing evidence for the role of financial incentives in physician behavior and the impact that this behavior may have on soaring health care expenditures in the U.S.

“In the same patient, a medical problem would be evaluated—and perhaps treated—differently by employed versus self-employed urologists,” Dr. John M. Hollingsworth, of the University of Michigan Medical School in Ann Arbor, who led the new study, told Reuters Health in an email.

While the volume of their work does not affect the salary of most employed physicians, the self-employed can take home extra cash by taking on additional patients or ordering more diagnostic tests, he and colleagues point out in the Journal of Urology. And with declining real-dollar incomes, this source of new revenue may be particularly alluring for some physicians.

The researchers looked at more than 37 million outpatient visits to urologists across the U.S., using data from the National Ambulatory Medical Care Survey conducted in 2006 and 2007. Four out of every five physicians surveyed were self-employed.

Overall, more than one in five urology visits resulted in imaging, they report.

Most of the imaging was indicated for a benign enlargement of the prostate, kidney stones or the presence of blood in the urine. Of the various imaging tests, urologists usually chose ultrasound.

This use of diagnostic testing did not vary by factors such as the patient’s age, gender or Medicaid eligibility, nor by the doctor’s practice type or location.

Self-employed urologists, however, were nearly twice as likely to order imaging compared to employed urologists: 24 percent versus 13 percent.

Profit motivations may be one of the forces driving this difference. But other possibilities exist, Hollingsworth noted, including patient preference, legal concerns and intolerance of medical ambiguity.

Regardless of the underlying reason, the practice could lead to unintended consequences for patients, including a modest increase in radiation exposure and over-diagnosis of “pseudo-disease,” Hollingsworth added.

The use of imaging has been on the rise in recent years, along with advances in the technologies behind the tools.

“With physicians controlling much of the demand for imaging, strategies to affect its use should consider the methods by which providers are compensated,” Hollingsworth said.

He added that these findings have direct relevance to some of the health care reform measures in the Affordable Care Act of 2010.

“Under the new healthcare law,” Hollingsworth told Reuters Health, “the Center for Medicare and Medicaid Innovation is charged with testing new reimbursement models, which include varying payment to physicians who order advanced diagnostic imaging services as defined according to the physician’s adherence to appropriateness criteria of such services.”

“It will be interesting to see how such a change will impact utilization among self-employed and employed urologists,” he said.

SOURCE: The Journal of Urology, online October 18, 2010.

The content on this site is for information only and is not a substitute for professional medical advice, diagnosis or treatment. If you cannot pass urine, have a fever with back or side pain, or sudden severe pain in the testicle, call 911 or go to an emergency department.

Urinary symptoms?

Weak stream, urgency, up at night? Score it in two minutes.

Seven questions from the International Prostate Symptom Score show whether symptoms are mild, moderate or severe, and when to see a doctor.

Take the symptom score

When to get help

Most urology problems can wait for an appointment. These can’t.

Call 911 or go to an emergency department if you have any of these:

  • You cannot pass urine at allAcute urinary retention: a painful, swollen bladder. It needs a catheter, often within hours.
  • Fever or chills with back or side painA blocked, infected kidney (for example behind a stone) can turn into sepsis quickly.
  • Sudden, severe pain in a testiclePossible testicular torsion. The testicle can often be saved only within about 6 hours.
  • An erection lasting over 4 hoursPriapism. Without treatment it can cause permanent damage.
Call 911

Outside the US, call your local emergency number.

See a doctor within days

  1. 01Blood in your urineEven once, and even without pain. Usually harmless, but it is the most common first sign of bladder and kidney cancer.
  2. 02Burning, frequent or cloudy urineTypical of a urinary tract infection, which usually clears with treatment.
  3. 03A lump or swelling in a testicleMost lumps are benign; testicular cancer is very treatable when found early.

General guidance only. If you are unsure how urgent a symptom is, call your doctor or a nurse advice line.