Skip to content

Urgent urology symptoms What to do

Prostate screening not saving lives, study says

Urology TodayPublished March 14, 20122 min read

Key points

  • A big study in Europe gives mixed results about prostate cancer screening that may do little to change minds about its value.
  • The results underscore a frustrating truth about this disease: most prostate cancers grow too slowly to threaten a man’s life and there is no good way to tell which ones will.
  • He had no role in the study, which was published in today’s New England Journal of Medicine.
  • The new research is a longer follow-up from the European study: 11-year results on 162,000 men ages 55 to 69.

A big study in Europe gives mixed results about prostate cancer screening that may do little to change minds about its value.

The study finds that PSA blood tests every four years seem to cut the risk of death from prostate cancer. But it also finds that screening makes no difference in overall mortality rates because most men die of other causes – not their prostate tumors.

The results underscore a frustrating truth about this disease: most prostate cancers grow too slowly to threaten a man’s life and there is no good way to tell which ones will. Finding cancer often leads to treatments that can cause impotence, incontinence and other problems. The PSA test also is just a measure of inflammation, which can be due to many things besides cancer.

“A man needs to make a choice for himself, realizing the benefits exist in theory, but the harms have been shown in every study that we’ve ever done in prostate cancer,” said Dr. Otis Brawley, chief medical officer of the American Cancer Society. “If there is an overall mortality benefit from prostate screening it is very, very small.”

He had no role in the study, which was published in today’s New England Journal of Medicine.

In October, a government-appointed panel of experts, the U.S. Preventive Services Task Force, recommended against screening with PSA tests. Only two big studies have looked at this — a U.S. one that found annual screening did not cut prostate cancer death risk and a European one that found screening every four years did. (In Europe, prostate screening is less common and is done at wider intervals than in the United States.)

The new research is a longer follow-up from the European study: 11-year results on 162,000 men ages 55 to 69. Researchers found that 1,055 men would need to be offered screening and 37 cancers would need to be detected to prevent a single death from prostate cancer.

About half of the cancers that were detected did not need to be treated, researchers estimate.

The study was led by Dr. Fritz Schroder of Erasmus University Medical Center in the Netherlands. Several authors hold patents or get fees from PSA tests.

Men who choose to be screened should be prepared for a tough discussion of whether to have a biopsy or to treat any cancer that is found, said Dr. Christopher Logothetis, a prostate cancer researcher.

###

By MARILYNN MARCHIONE • Associated Press

The content on this site is for information only and is not a substitute for professional medical advice, diagnosis or treatment. If you cannot pass urine, have a fever with back or side pain, or sudden severe pain in the testicle, call 911 or go to an emergency department.

Urinary symptoms?

Weak stream, urgency, up at night? Score it in two minutes.

Seven questions from the International Prostate Symptom Score show whether symptoms are mild, moderate or severe, and when to see a doctor.

Take the symptom score

When to get help

Most urology problems can wait for an appointment. These can’t.

Call 911 or go to an emergency department if you have any of these:

  • You cannot pass urine at allAcute urinary retention: a painful, swollen bladder. It needs a catheter, often within hours.
  • Fever or chills with back or side painA blocked, infected kidney (for example behind a stone) can turn into sepsis quickly.
  • Sudden, severe pain in a testiclePossible testicular torsion. The testicle can often be saved only within about 6 hours.
  • An erection lasting over 4 hoursPriapism. Without treatment it can cause permanent damage.
Call 911

Outside the US, call your local emergency number.

See a doctor within days

  1. 01Blood in your urineEven once, and even without pain. Usually harmless, but it is the most common first sign of bladder and kidney cancer.
  2. 02Burning, frequent or cloudy urineTypical of a urinary tract infection, which usually clears with treatment.
  3. 03A lump or swelling in a testicleMost lumps are benign; testicular cancer is very treatable when found early.

General guidance only. If you are unsure how urgent a symptom is, call your doctor or a nurse advice line.