Skip to content

Urgent urology symptoms What to do

Prostate cancer screening may help healthy men only

Urology TodayPublished November 2, 20103 min read

Key points

  • Screening men for prostate cancer makes sense only if they are generally healthy, U.S. researchers said on Monday.
  • Today, doctors commonly screen men over 50 for prostate cancer using a prostate-specific antigen (PSA) blood test, which costs $50 or more.
  • So those treatments—with their risks of side effects like erectile dysfunction and urinary incontinence—can potentially do more harm than good for many men.
  • For the new study, doctors re-analyzed data from an earlier report that found no difference in death rates among more than 70,000 men who had been randomly assigned to annual screening or usual care.

Screening men for prostate cancer makes sense only if they are generally healthy, U.S. researchers said on Monday.

They found that even if screening doesn’t help men live longer overall—as shown by a large U.S. study last year—it’s possible that some may still benefit.

Today, doctors commonly screen men over 50 for prostate cancer using a prostate-specific antigen (PSA) blood test, which costs $50 or more.

This practice is controversial, however, because prostate tumors are often slow-growing, and screening may result in many men undergoing surgery, radiation or other treatments for cancers that would never have threatened their lives.

So those treatments—with their risks of side effects like erectile dysfunction and urinary incontinence—can potentially do more harm than good for many men.

U.S. federal health officials are currently looking into the issue, but so far say the evidence is insufficient to make sweeping recommendations for men younger than age 75. For those more senior, the U.S. Preventive Services Task Force discourages screening.

For the new study, doctors re-analyzed data from an earlier report that found no difference in death rates among more than 70,000 men who had been randomly assigned to annual screening or usual care.

Over ten years, prostate cancer killed about two in 1,000 men. And screening did nothing to help those who had health problems that put them at risk of dying from heart disease or cancer, two major killers in the US.

But it slashed the rate of cancer deaths by nearly half in the 26,000 men who didn’t have such issues. That means 723 men would have to be screened and five would have to be treated to prevent one prostate cancer death at ten years.

“The reason why the original study appeared to be negative is it looked at all patients,” said Dr. Anthony V. D’Amico, an oncologist at Brigham and Women’s Hospital in Boston, who worked on the new analysis.

“What this study suggests is that PSA tests could be used more selectively in men who are in good health,” he told Reuters Health. “For men who aren’t as healthy, it suggests that screening may not make a difference.”

An unhealthy 60-year-old, D’Amico explained, might simply not live long enough to reap the benefits of removing slow-growing tumors.

Dr. Ned Calonge, who heads the U.S. Preventive Services Task Force, cautioned that analyses based on earlier data could often lead to “exaggerated or mistaken conclusions.”

He noted, for instance, that the less-healthy men who were screened appeared to have a higher risk of dying from prostate cancer than those who weren’t—a finding that is hard to explain.

“This does not trump the results of the original study,” he told Reuters Health by e-mail, “but provides an interesting finding that may prompt additional research on this issue.”

SOURCE: Journal of Clinical Oncology, online November 1, 2010.

The content on this site is for information only and is not a substitute for professional medical advice, diagnosis or treatment. If you cannot pass urine, have a fever with back or side pain, or sudden severe pain in the testicle, call 911 or go to an emergency department.

Urinary symptoms?

Weak stream, urgency, up at night? Score it in two minutes.

Seven questions from the International Prostate Symptom Score show whether symptoms are mild, moderate or severe, and when to see a doctor.

Take the symptom score

When to get help

Most urology problems can wait for an appointment. These can’t.

Call 911 or go to an emergency department if you have any of these:

  • You cannot pass urine at allAcute urinary retention: a painful, swollen bladder. It needs a catheter, often within hours.
  • Fever or chills with back or side painA blocked, infected kidney (for example behind a stone) can turn into sepsis quickly.
  • Sudden, severe pain in a testiclePossible testicular torsion. The testicle can often be saved only within about 6 hours.
  • An erection lasting over 4 hoursPriapism. Without treatment it can cause permanent damage.
Call 911

Outside the US, call your local emergency number.

See a doctor within days

  1. 01Blood in your urineEven once, and even without pain. Usually harmless, but it is the most common first sign of bladder and kidney cancer.
  2. 02Burning, frequent or cloudy urineTypical of a urinary tract infection, which usually clears with treatment.
  3. 03A lump or swelling in a testicleMost lumps are benign; testicular cancer is very treatable when found early.

General guidance only. If you are unsure how urgent a symptom is, call your doctor or a nurse advice line.