Skip to content

Urgent urology symptoms What to do

Men’s hopes for robot prostate surgery unrealistic

Urology TodayPublished January 26, 20125 min read

Key points

  • Robot-assisted surgery for prostate cancer has been heavily hyped, and a new study suggests that men’s expectations of the surgery may be too high.
  • Prostate removal is one treatment option for prostate cancer, and in the U.S., a majority of those surgeries are now done with the help of a “robot.”
  • And after hospitals invest the roughly $1.5 million for the machines, plus the cost of surgeon training and annual service contracts, they often aggressively market the approach—as do the companies behind the technology.
  • “Since about the mid-2000s, people were thinking that robotic surgery was the greatest thing since sliced bread,” said Dr.

Robot-assisted surgery for prostate cancer has been heavily hyped, and a new study suggests that men’s expectations of the surgery may be too high.

Researchers found that of 171 men facing prostate cancer surgery, those having robotic surgery expected a shorter hospital stay, and a quicker return to their usual physical activity and sex life.

But those hopes may not be realistic.

Prostate removal is one treatment option for prostate cancer, and in the U.S., a majority of those surgeries are now done with the help of a “robot.”

During the procedure, the surgeon sits at a console, operating robotic “arms” that extract the prostate gland through small cuts in the abdomen.

The robotic approach is expensive. And after hospitals invest the roughly $1.5 million for the machines, plus the cost of surgeon training and annual service contracts, they often aggressively market the approach—as do the companies behind the technology.

And that may include claims that robotic surgery is better than the old-fashioned way.

“Since about the mid-2000s, people were thinking that robotic surgery was the greatest thing since sliced bread,” said Dr. Judd W. Moul, a prostate surgeon at Duke University Medical Center who led the new study.

There was reason to believe that the better visualization with robotic surgery could lead to some better outcomes, Moul told Reuters Health.

On the other hand, he said, when surgeons actually use their hands, they get “tactile feedback” that’s missing with the robotic approach.

And studies have suggested that while robotic surgery may have some short-term advantages—like a somewhat shorter hospital stay—there may be no clear difference in the most important outcomes.

So far, there’s no good evidence that robotic-surgery patients fare any better as far as cancer recurrence or long-term side effects like urine leakage and erectile dysfunction.

And in an earlier study, Moul and his colleagues found that men who had the robotic procedure were actually less satisfied in the long run than those who had traditional surgery.

They guessed that patients’ expectations going into surgery might have something to do with it.

MORE OPTIMISM WITH ROBOTIC SURGERY

So for the new study, they surveyed 171 men about their expectations heading into prostate cancer surgery. The majority of patients—97—had opted for robotic surgery, while 74 were going with the traditional route.

Overall, 89 percent men having the robotic surgery expected to stay just one night in the hospital, versus 37 percent of men having traditional surgery.

The robotic-surgery group also thought they would be back to exercising sooner—typically predicting a five-week wait, versus six weeks in the other group. And they expected to have recovered their erectile function within five months of surgery.

Men having traditional surgery were much less optimistic. They typically assumed it would take nine months to regain their sex life.

On average, Moul said, men having robotic surgery do seem to get out of the hospital eight to 12 hours quicker.

But a small percentage, he noted, end up staying in the hospital for a few days because their bowel function does not return quickly.

As far as physical activity and long-term erectile function, it’s not clear if there’s any advantage to robotic surgery. At Duke, Moul noted, men are advised to avoid any heavy lifting for six weeks after surgery—robot or not.

ASK TOUGH QUESTIONS

Where are men getting their expectations? Ads, the Internet and the general belief that high-tech must be better may all play a role, according to Moul.

“But I think that probably physician counseling has a lot to do with it,” Moul said.

He noted that surgeons do have an incentive to push men toward the new technology in order to “work through their learning curve”—that is, hone their skills by doing more procedures.

Increasingly, experts are saying that men should put more stock in their surgeon’s experience than on the type of prostate surgery.

Moul agreed. That experience, he said, “is what drives the long-term outcomes of urinary and sexual recovery of function.”

“Ask your surgeon the tough questions,” Moul said. That means asking how many procedures he or she has ever done, and how many per year.

There’s no hard-and-fast number that defines a “good” surgeon. But Moul suggested that a doctor who performs at least 40 to 75 procedures a year (of one specific kind—robot or traditional) would be considered experienced.

Of course, that all assumes a man has decided on having surgery.

Many men with early-stage prostate cancer can decide to hold off on treatment altogether. That’s because prostate tumors are often slow-growing and may never advance to the point of threatening a man’s life.

One study found that more than 120,000 American men diagnosed with prostate cancer every year are ideal candidates for “watchful waiting”—which means doctors keep an eye on the cancer to see if it’s progressing.

In reality, though, the majority of those men end up having surgery, radiation or other treatment instead.

SOURCE: Journal of Urology, online January 16, 2012.

The content on this site is for information only and is not a substitute for professional medical advice, diagnosis or treatment. If you cannot pass urine, have a fever with back or side pain, or sudden severe pain in the testicle, call 911 or go to an emergency department.

Urinary symptoms?

Weak stream, urgency, up at night? Score it in two minutes.

Seven questions from the International Prostate Symptom Score show whether symptoms are mild, moderate or severe, and when to see a doctor.

Take the symptom score

When to get help

Most urology problems can wait for an appointment. These can’t.

Call 911 or go to an emergency department if you have any of these:

  • You cannot pass urine at allAcute urinary retention: a painful, swollen bladder. It needs a catheter, often within hours.
  • Fever or chills with back or side painA blocked, infected kidney (for example behind a stone) can turn into sepsis quickly.
  • Sudden, severe pain in a testiclePossible testicular torsion. The testicle can often be saved only within about 6 hours.
  • An erection lasting over 4 hoursPriapism. Without treatment it can cause permanent damage.
Call 911

Outside the US, call your local emergency number.

See a doctor within days

  1. 01Blood in your urineEven once, and even without pain. Usually harmless, but it is the most common first sign of bladder and kidney cancer.
  2. 02Burning, frequent or cloudy urineTypical of a urinary tract infection, which usually clears with treatment.
  3. 03A lump or swelling in a testicleMost lumps are benign; testicular cancer is very treatable when found early.

General guidance only. If you are unsure how urgent a symptom is, call your doctor or a nurse advice line.